Is a Photo Vault Backup in iCloud or Google Drive Really Private?
What end-to-end encrypted backup means for a photo vault, who holds the keys, and the questions to ask of any vault app.
"Backed up to the cloud" can mean two very different things, and the difference is who holds the key.
Encrypted in transit and at rest
Most cloud storage encrypts your files on its servers with keys the provider holds. That protects against a stolen hard drive. It does not stop the provider, or someone who takes over your account, from reading them.
Encrypted before upload
With end-to-end encryption the app scrambles each file on your phone, with a key that never leaves it unprotected, and uploads only the result. The storage company holds data it cannot read. A person who gets into your account gets the same unreadable data.
Questions to ask of a vault app
- Whose servers hold the backup: the vault company's, or your own iCloud or Google Drive?
- Is it encrypted on the phone, before upload?
- What opens it on a new phone, and how strong is that?
- Can you turn it off and delete the cloud copy?
Where the weak point moves to
When the storage company cannot read the backup, its strength is whatever unlocks it on a new device. A short PIN or pattern can be guessed by a determined attacker who already has your cloud account. A long recovery phrase cannot.
How Vaultan does it
Vaultan encrypts every file with AES-256 on the phone and stores the backup in your own iCloud or Google Drive under random file names. By default it opens on a new device with the vault's pattern; "Extra protection for new devices" requires the recovery phrase instead. You can turn backup off for any vault and delete its cloud copy.
